From nature to virtue : moral formation and community in novels by Charlotte Yonge and Elizabeth Gaskell.




Barker, Alisha M.

Access rights

Worldwide access

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title



This thesis explores how novels by Charlotte Yonge and Elizabeth Gaskell contest popular Victorian assumptions that moral influence stems from maternal nature. By offering virtue as the true source of moral influence, these authors also challenge Victorian ideas about who should be involved in the moral formation of the young. In this thesis, I first examine how these authors' portrayals of bad mothers demonstrate their belief that maternal instinct is distinct from a woman's ability to be a positive moral influence on her children. Next, I consider how Yonge's and Gaskell's frequent use of virtuous female mentors demonstrates their belief that moral formation is both a communal activity and social duty. Finally, I explore how understanding the virtue that enables moral influence as domestic rather than feminine leads Yonge and Gaskell to portray fathers and male mentors who play a significant role in the moral formation of young people.


Includes bibliographical references (p. 94-97).


Yonge, Charlotte Mary, 1823-1901 -- Criticism and interpretation., Gaskell, Elizabeth Cleghorn, 1810-1865 -- Criticism and interpretation., Virtue in literature., Motherhood in literature., Moral development in literature.